20 Best Broadheads (2020): Buyer’s Guide and Unbiased Reviews

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Are you on a quest to find the best broadheads?

Then you’re in the right place. Because I have done the hard work for you and have reviewed dozens of products to bring you the best broadheads.

In addition, I will introduce the following related topics.

  • Product Details (Including advantages and disadvantages) 
  • Broadheads Buyer’s Guide
  • Types of Broadheads
  • Compatibility of Broadhead and Bow
  • Safety Guidelines for Broadheads

I will also answer some common questions.

  • Which are the best broadheads for hunters to use?
  • Which broadhead should be used for which game?
  • How to sharpen broadhead blades?
  • Should I select a 4-blade or 3-blade broadhead?
  • Which broadhead is best suited for angled shots?
  • Which one is better: mechanical broadhead or fixed broadhead?

Without further ado, let’s begin!

Chief Editor


Hours Researching

Products Evaluated

Reviews Considered

Researched Sources

Top 3 Picks ( In a Hurry? Here are the winners )

Editor’s Choice & Best Seller
RAGE Crossbow X, 2-Blade Archery Arrow Broadhead, 100 or 125 Grain with Shock Collar Technology (3-Pack)
Professional's Choice
G 5 Outdoors Montec 100 Grain 1-1/16" Cut Broadheads (3 Pack)
Best Value
Muzzy 209-MX4, Bowhunting 100 Grain, .025" 4 Blade Broadhead, 1-1/8" Cutting Diameter, 3 Pack
RAGE Crossbow X, 2-Blade Archery Arrow Broadhead, 100 or 125 Grain with Shock Collar Technology (3-Pack)
G 5 Outdoors Montec 100 Grain 1-1/16" Cut Broadheads (3 Pack)
Muzzy 209-MX4, Bowhunting 100 Grain, .025" 4 Blade Broadhead, 1-1/8" Cutting Diameter, 3 Pack
Our Rating
Editor’s Choice & Best Seller
RAGE Crossbow X, 2-Blade Archery Arrow Broadhead, 100 or 125 Grain with Shock Collar Technology (3-Pack)
RAGE Crossbow X, 2-Blade Archery Arrow Broadhead, 100 or 125 Grain with Shock Collar Technology (3-Pack)
Our Rating
Read Full Review
View on Amazon
Professional's Choice
G 5 Outdoors Montec 100 Grain 1-1/16" Cut Broadheads (3 Pack)
G 5 Outdoors Montec 100 Grain 1-1/16" Cut Broadheads (3 Pack)
Our Rating
Read Full Review
View on Amazon
Best Value
Muzzy 209-MX4, Bowhunting 100 Grain, .025" 4 Blade Broadhead, 1-1/8" Cutting Diameter, 3 Pack
Muzzy 209-MX4, Bowhunting 100 Grain, .025" 4 Blade Broadhead, 1-1/8" Cutting Diameter, 3 Pack
Our Rating
Read Full Review
View on Amazon

Best Broadheads

Game hunting has been a part of life since the dawn of man. Today, game hunting has become a sport, instead of a necessity of life. The crossbow combines the accuracy of a rifle with the greater challenge of a bow. Hunters who love a little extra challenge enjoy using a crossbow to hunt deer, turkeys, and other wild game. The broadhead is the razor-sharp head on the bolt that penetrates the hide to stop your prey. A high-quality broadhead provides greater accuracy and dropping power. You want a broadhead which stops an animal on the first shot, instead of injuring it. Your choice of broadheads is critical when preparing to hunt with a crossbow.

1. Rage 510306 Crossbowx 2-Blade Broadhead 100gr 2in Cut 3pk 53000 – Editor’s Choice & Best Seller

RAGE Crossbow X, 2-Blade Archery Arrow Broadhead, 100 or 125 Grain with Shock Collar Technology (3-Pack)
  • PRECISION - Rage broadheads are known for their accuracy and their...
  • MASSIVE CUTTING SURFACES – Rear-deploying, SlipCam design with huge...
  • TECHNOLOGY - Improved Shock Collar Technology ensures proper blade...
  • 3 PACK - 100 grain broadhead. Also available in 125 grain. Replacement...
  • RAGE - Leading the Evolution in Mechanical broadheads

At first glance, you notice the Rage Bowhunting CrossbowX broadhead is different. It has a unique cutting surface designed for deeper penetration and quick humane kills. The broadhead looks like a set of airplane wings complete with stabilizers. This guarantees straight flight of the bolt, ensuring accuracy in your shot.

The broadhead uses Ferrule Alignment Technology (F.A.T.) for improved aerodynamics which increases range and flight accuracy. The broadhead is built with a shock collar which helps reduce the chances of the broadhead snapping off of the bolt.

The stainless steel blades are extremely sharp, giving maximum penetration. The Rage Bowhunting CrossbowX broadheads are sold in 3-packs and also includes a practice head so you can practice without damaging your hunting broadheads. They come in 100 and 125-grain options.

  • Tough stainless steel blades
  • Razor sharp edges
  • 100 and 125-grain options
  • Free practice head in each pack
  • F.A.T. gives greater accuracy
  • Shock collars could be tougher, the weakest point of the broadhead

2. Muzzy Bowhunting Broadheads 3 Blades Trocar Tip, 75, 100 or 125 Grain

No products found.

The Muzzy triple blade broadheads are sold in 6-packs and are offered in three weight a 75-grain, 100-grain, and 125-grain. The 3 blade edges are extremely sharp, possibly sharp enough to shave with. The end of the broadhead is tipped with a hardened steel Trocar tip for deeper penetration and to protect the edges of the blades on impact. The three blades lock into the head of the broadhead keeping them secured during the shot and when you remove them from your kill.

The Muzzy broadhead is perfect for use when hunting large game. The tip strength and razor sharp blades will easily penetrate the hair and tough hides of game like bears, deer, and elk. The hardened steel tip will not break even when piercing pones. The two heavier broadheads have a 1-3/16” diameter cut, while the 75-grain has a 1” diameter. The bolts will drop large game quickly.

The blades on the Muzzy stay sharp even after repeated shots. The broadhead makes a light whistling noise during flight, which could alert game if you miss your shot. The 6-pack includes a bonus practice head for safe target practice.

  • Superior blade sharpness
  • Good cutting diameter
  • Deep penetrating broadhead
  • Excellent for large game
  • The small whistling sound on shots
  • Will go completely through the small game.

3. Swhacker Set of 3-100 Grain 2 Inch Cut Broadheads

Swhacker SWH00207 #207 2 Inch Cut Broadheads Set of 3-100 Grain, Green, 2"
  • Each set includes 3 broadheads
  • 100 Grain Expandable 2-Blade Broadhead
  • Blade: .032" thick, stainless steel, honed razor sharp
  • Ferrule: Anodized aircraft aluminum
  • Hardened high carbon steel point

The Swhacker broadhead looks like a fighter jet ready to take flight but is much faster. The ferrule takes its cue from a fighter jet, is made from aircraft-grade aluminum. The 2” wide cutting surface provides superior killing power, so you stop your game quick, not leaving them wandering around injured. The stainless steel blades hold up to all kinds of conditions and last for years of hunting.

The tip of the broadhead is made from high-carbon steel to increase penetrating power and for better durability. The dual blade broadheads come in 3-packs and come in only a 100-grain weight.

The is a dual-blade broadhead. The first set of edges are 1” in diameter and provide penetration through the skin and ribs. Upon contact, the blades flip open exposing the 2” cutting blades with cut through internal organs providing a quick and humane kill. Some hunters report being able to hear the “swhack” sound as the blades pop to their full 2” width.

  • The unique dual-blade cutting system allows for quick penetration and quick kills.
  • High-quality hardened steel and aircraft-grade aluminum construction
  • 2” cutting surface for sure kills
  • Blades honed to razor sharpness
  • Instructional DVD does not work for all users.
  • No practice broadhead included.

4. G5 Outdoors Montec 100 Grain All-Steel Premium Broadheads – Professional’s Choice

G 5 Outdoors Montec 100 Grain 1-1/16" Cut Broadheads (3 Pack)
  • The blade angle is designed to allow for repeated maximum penetration...
  • One-Piece Metal Injection Molding Construction, with no parts needed...
  • Due to the strong tapered blade design's and angle it allows the...
  • 3 Broadheads Per Pack
  • 1" to 1 1/8" Cutting Diameter

Simple, functional, accurate, and powerful, are just a few of the words you could use to describe the Montec G5 broadheads. The broadheads do not use the latest technology. They do not have special features as some of our other choices. They don’t have moving blades. They are a simple fixed blade broadhead designed for deep penetration and killing power.

The G5 broadhead is made from 100% stainless steel using a one-piece injection molding process. This creates a strong and durable broadhead which requires no maintenance and has no replaceable parts. It is a simple three blade design which flies true. You simply screw it onto your bolt and you are ready to shoot.

The tapered blade design makes it easy to sharpen the blades is they ever get nicked or dulled. The broadhead is strong and will stand up to repeated hunts with ease. If you like the simplicity of a fixed blade broadhead, this could be your best choice.

  • Can be re-sharpened
  • Simple to use
  • No maintenance
  • Deep penetration
  • True flight
  • Low Cost
  • A quick change of broadheads
  • Sharpening is not easy
  • Some hunters report noise during flight

5. Rage Hypodermic

No products found.

Rage broadheads are famous for two features. First, they are among the most accurate broadheads on the market. Second, they make wide cuts leaving easy to follow blood trails and sure kills. The Rage Hypodermic is narrow during flight making for fast accurate flight, but at the moment of penetration, the 2” blades fly open cutting through internal organs making sure your shot is effective.

Rage uses a unique shock collar blade-retention design to guarantee the 2” blades stay in place during flight and only pop open when contact is made.

Rage sells the Hypodermic broadhead in 3-packs and bundles a free practice head in each pack. The broadheads are available in both a 100-grain and 125-grain weight.

The 2” cutting blades are not where the story starts. Rage uses a hybrid tip on this broadhead which is hypodermic needle sharp for instant penetration through the toughest hide. The tip is encased in steel ferrule to make sure the tip and broadhead so strong and durable.

  • Great blade retention with Rage’s Shock Collar Tech
  • Hypodermic needle sharp tip
  • Free practice head
  • Steel ferrule
  • 2” cutting blades make for humane kills
  • Stabilizer rings are not as strong as some broadheads, handle cautiously.

6. Grim Reaper Razor Tip Whitetail Special 2-Inch 3 Blade

Grim Reaper Razortip Broadhead Whitetail Special 100gr 2in 3pk
  • Designed for higher kinetic energy bows
  • Stainless steel mechanical broadhead
  • 2" cutting diameter
  • Specially designed for higher kinetic energy Bows and Whitetail sized...
  • 035-Inch Thick Blades

Grim Reaper Broadheads are not as well known, which is a tragedy. These 3-blade broadheads provide a 2” cutting surface which will drop a whitetail deer in a few steps. The collapsed head provides great speed and accuracy during flight and then instantly flies open to create a massive kill channel. The hardened tip penetrates hide and bone with ease.

The Grim Reaper Razor Tip is designed for hunting larger game like whitetail deer. Their mechanical opening system works great on high-energy bows and crossbow bolts. They are simple to use since they do not require o-rings or bands for installation. The blades are secured using Grim Reaper’s tension system until penetration.

These broadheads fly true and quiet with no rattle or whistle. The tip penetrates quickly, then the blades take over to cut through organs to stop your deer in a few yards. Even if the deer manages to move away, you will find an easy to follow the blood trail.

The blades tuck away tightly into the broadhead providing an aerodynamic flight surface. The broadheads work great even when your shot must be taken from an angle. They penetrate and stay on track without deflection.

  • Quiet flight
  • Rugged design without the need for O-rings
  • Quick kill capability
  • Flies accurately
  • Easy to tune and adjust the head
  • Blades can be replaced
  • Works great on high-energy crossbows
  • Hunters report the broadhead may bend when striking bone.

7. Carbon Express XT Dual Blade Serrated Crossbow Broadhead

Carbon Express XT Dual Blade Serrated Crossbow Broadhead, 100 Grain Weight, 3-Pack
  • MAXIMUM DAMAGE - Six cutting edges which create up to a 250% greater...
  • FIELD POINT ACCURACY - aerodynamic profile and 100% spin testing...
  • PRO GRADE DESIGN - 1 1/8" cutting diameter, aircraft grade aluminum...
  • LONG LASTING - Serrated blades stay sharp longer
  • 100 GRAIN

You can instantly see the difference in these broadheads. The Carbon Express DT Dual Blade features serrated edges, but that is not the only difference in appearance. Their six-cutting edges are spread over three blades. The blade design produces a 250% greater wound opening when compared to traditional fixed blade designs.

The blade is designed to give a greater aerodynamic performance. The main blade splits the air and then feeds it over the other two blades. Carbon Express conducted extensive spin testing to create a design which flies true, fast and maintains power. The broadheads come in 3-packs and are offered in both a 100-grain and 125-grain size.

The 1.125” cutting edge sounds small compared to some of our other broadheads, but this is a fixed blade design which provides better durability. Aircraft-grade aluminum was used for the ferrule. The blades are 100% stainless steel with a serrated edge for better bone cutting power. The broadheads work great on both carbon and aluminum bolts.

Hunters report the Carbon Express XT broadheads hold-up over numerous hunts, which cuts your hunting expense. They also point out the broadheads great flight performance and killing power. The broadheads provide humane kills and good blood trails if you need to track your game after the shot.

The fixed head design utilized by Carbon Express provides a great balance of killing power, accuracy, and value. Their innovative blade pattern provides greater wound openings to ensure more successful kills and less tracking of injured game.

  • Serrated blade provides a powerful cutting action
  • Strong and durable design
  • Accurate flight
  • Larger wounds for quicker kills and easy to follow blood trails
  • While durable compared to opening blades, the blades can bend after multiple uses.

8. Muzzy 209-MX4, Bowhunting 100 Grain, .025″ 4 Blade Broadhead, 1-1/8″ Cutting Diameter – Best Value

Muzzy 209-MX4, Bowhunting 100 Grain, .025" 4 Blade Broadhead, 1-1/8" Cutting Diameter, 3 Pack
  • DESIGNED TO THE MAX - Designed for Max Speed, Max Strength, and Max...
  • DEEP PENETRATION - The MX Series has a shorter profile, 1-1/8"...
  • BONE SHATTERING TIP - The Trocar Tip provides superior penetration
  • RAZOR SHARP, DEPENDABLE, and DURABLE - High-grade aircraft aluminum...
  • MADE IN THE USA -Founded in 1984, Muzzy is the number one name in...

You may have noticed this is our second Muzzy broadhead, that’s for good a good reason. Muzzy does their research by working with the top crossbow designers to build fixed blade broadheads that work flawlessly.

The MX4 is made from high-quality steel. It features a short-profile design to keep weight down and for better flight accuracy. The lower weight allows your bolt to fly farther while maintaining good stopping power.

The MX4 uses a 4 blade pattern to increase the size of the wound and to provide an easy to follow the blood trail.

The tip of the broadhead is sharp to the touch and penetrates hide instantly and blasts through bones. The tip maintains sharpness even after use. The blades are .025” thick and provide a gaping 1.125” cutting pattern.

This Muzzy broadhead is considered one of the most effective fixed-blade broadheads available. The blades are razor sharp and durable. They are priced reasonably and available in 3-packs. The 4-blade design provides for accurate flight and pass-through power. The blades are replaceable when they become dull.

The Muzzy MX4 is a favorite of beginners due to the simplicity of use and low price, but experienced crossbow hunters turn to the MX4 for its precision, kill-power, and durability. If you hate the complexity of blade-opening broadheads, take a close look at the MX4. It provides impressive kill power while maintaining ease of use.

  • 4-Blade design provides larger wounds.
  • Trocar tip shatters bones to provide superior penetration
  • Extremely sharp blades
  • Tough and durable design
  • Accurate flight
  • Crossbow hunters report needing to fine-tune sighting due to flight pattern of MX4

9. Muzzy 209 Bowhunting 100 Grain, 4 Blade Broadhead, 1″ Cutting Diameter

Muzzy 209 Bowhunting 100 Grain, 4 Blade Broadhead, 1" Cutting Diameter, 6 Pack
  • BONE CRUSHING PENETRATION – Hardened steel Trocar tip provides...
  • 100 GRAIN BROADHEADS - 4 Blade broadhead for use in standard inserts -...
  • CUTTING DIAMETER - .020 inch blades with 1" cutting diameter. Anodized...
  • STAINLESS STEEL - Vented stainless steel blades. gives you cut on...
  • MADE IN THE USA -Founded in 1984, Muzzy is the number one name in...

No, we are not stuck on Muzzy, but you might be soon. This Muzzy 4-blade broadhead is available in both a 90-grain and 100-grain size. Both weights have a 1” diameter blade design which provides incredible flight and good killing power.

This Muzzy model has been on the market for years, and we suspect crossbow hunters would scream in pain is they were replaced. They are very affordable and are one of the most reliable broadheads on the market.

Are you tired of messing around with complicated broadheads? Muzzy created this broadhead to be a simple screw on and fire solution. Of course, you need to adjust your sighting, but beyond that, they are simple to use and work great. The steel Trocar tip pierces hide instantly and then crushes through bone allowing the blades to inflict killing damage instantly.

Experience deer and elk hunters and guides use this Muzzy broadhead as their “go to” solution. They know it will work in any conditions and never fail them. They don’t have to worry about mechanical failure, they just need to go pick up their game after a successful shot. If you want a consistent shot with impressive kill power, these simple 1” broadheads are the answer.

  • Silent flight
  • Trocar steel tip for great bone punch through
  • 6-packs at 3-pack pricing
  • Simple to use
  • Replaceable blades
  • Smaller cutting diameter means smaller blood trails and less killing power.
  • Blades will twist if you hit a rock or tree. (Remember, replaceable blades.)

10. Muzzy Trocar 100 Grain 3-Blade Broadhead

Muzzy Trocar 100 Grain 3-Blade Broadhead – 3 Pack
  • Country Of Origin : United States
  • The Package Height Of The Product Is 1.25 Inches
  • The Package Length Of The Product Is 9.6 Inches
  • The Package Width Of The Product Is 5.6 Inches
  • 100 Grain 3 Blade

The 1” diameter of our last choice doesn’t work for everyone, so Muzzy created the Muzzy Trocar 100. This is a 100-grain 3-blade design which packs a wallop. The aerodynamic helix design improves flight speed and accuracy. The quick flight provides easier kills, as does the larger 1-3/16” diameter cutting pattern. Muzzy bundles them in 3-packs.

Muzzy used a solid steel ferrule to provide added strength and blade security. This makes sure the blades do not shift even when slicing through bone. The wide diameter cuts provide quick humane kills with impressive blood trails.

This is a simple fixed blade broadhead, so no tinkering around securing mechanical blades or making adjustments. You just screw them on and wait for your shot. The blades are super sharp cutting through hide, bones, and organs with ease.

  • Precise shooting due to good aerodynamic design
  • Blades are sharp enough to slice through bones, hide, and organs.
  • Trocar tip shatters bones with ease.
  • Short profile improves precision.
  • Blades are replaceable, but requires a little effort and an Allen wrench.

More Products (Our Rating: 4 Stars)

11. NAP Spitfire Mechancial Broadhead 100 Grain Three Blade Cut on Contact 3 Pack
NAP Spitfire Mechancial Broadhead 100 Grain Three Blade Cut on Contact 3 Pack
  • Archery Crossbow Arrow Broadheads
  • 100 Grain
  • 3 Per Pack
12. Sinbadteck Hunting Broadheads
Sinbadteck Hunting Broadheads, 12PCS 3 Blades Archery Broadheads 100 Grain Screw-in Arrow Heads Arrow Tips...
  • 【EASY INSTALL】- 100 grain broadheads with 3 extremely sharp fixed...
  • 【REMARKABLE PRECISION】- 2.8" stainless steel blades specially...
  • 【DURABLE & SHARP】- The hunting bow tips are manufactured using an...
  • 【NOTE】-12PCS Pack , The Archery Broadheads don't include the...
  • 【Life-time Technic Service] Sinbadteck PROVIDED 45-day return &...
13. Muzzy Broadheads New Muzzy Trocar Crossbow 125 Grain 3 Blade with Offset Blade Design
Muzzy Broadheads New Muzzy Trocar Crossbow 125 Grain 3 Blade with Offset Blade Design (3-Pack)
  • AERODYNAMIC - .035" right-helix design maximize arrow stabilization...
  • IMPROVED PENETRATION AND FLIGHT - Larger diameter ferrule to match...
  • BONE SHATTERING TIP – Hardened steel Trocar tip provides superior...
  • LARGE CUTTING DIAMETER – 3 fixed-blade broadhead with offset blade...
  • MADE IN THE USA -Founded in 1984, Muzzy is the number one name in...
14. Muzzy Trocar HB Hybrid 4 Blade Broadhead
Muzzy Trocar HB Hybrid 4 Blade Broadhead
  • HYBRID BROADHEAD - Two rear-deploying expandable blades are highly...
  • 2-5/8” TOTAL CUTTING SURFACE – the 4-blade broadhead features a...
  • AERODYNAMIC - .035" offset fixed blades deliver pinpoint accuracy at...
  • BONE SHATTERING TIP – Hardened steel Trocar tip provides superior...
  • MADE IN THE USA -Founded in 1984, Muzzy is the number one name in...
15. G5 Outdoors Small Game Broadheads
G5 150 Small Game Head Broadhead 100 Gr SS 3 Bld, 3-Pack, 1-InchDia
  • Available in 100 and 125 Grains
  • Provides a "shock and rip" action that stops small game in its tracks!
  • Perfect for hunting small game species with any type of bow at any...
  • 3 Broadheads Per Pack
  • 1" Cutting Diameter
16. Stinger Buzzcut 4 Blade Arrow Broadhead (Pack of 3), 100-Grain
Stinger Buzzcut 4 Blade Arrow Broadhead (Pack of 3), 100-Grain
  • Lifetime replacement
  • Available in 85 100 125 and 150grain
  • Spin tested
  • Lifetime replacement guarantee
  • Available in 85 100 125 and 150grain
17. QAD Exodus 100Gr Nonbarb (Full)
QAD Exodus 100Gr Nonbarb (Full)
  • 100 Grain Weight
  • Blade type: full
  • 1. 25" cutting diameter
  • . 40" blade thickness
  • Replaceable blades
18. Flying Arrow Archery T3100 Toxic Broadhead Blade
Flying Arrow Archery T3100 Toxic Broadhead Blade, Silver, 100-Grain
  • 7/8"-1" Cutting Diameter
  • Massive bone crushing chisel tip
  • Toxic & Cyclone 100 Grain Blades are interchangeable
  • Meatworm Technology
  • RCD (Radical Core Decompression Technology)
19. Muzzy 4100 Bowhunting Phantom 4 Blade 100 Grain Broadhead
Muzzy 4100 Bowhunting Phantom 4 Blade 100 Grain Broadhead, 1-1/8" Cutting Diameter, 3 Pack
  • BONE CRUSHING PENETRATION – The Muzzy Phantom 4-Blade broadheads are...
  • 100 GRAIN BROADHEADS - .036" Main blade, and .028" Bleeder blade (80...
  • CUTTING DIAMETER - 1-1/8" Designed to fit all carbon and aluminum...
  • AIRCRAFT ALUMINUM FERRULE - Adds strength while the straight edge...
  • MADE IN THE USA -Founded in 1984, Muzzy is the number one name in...
20. Quality Archery Designs QAD EXODUS BROADHEAD 125 Grain Full Blade
Quality Archery Designs QAD Exodus Broadhead 125 Grain Full Blade
  • Stainless steel construction. Compact, heavy-duty head promises...
  • Steeper cutting angle enhances penetration and pass-through. Shorter...
  • Rock-Buster hardened SST tip for added strength. Fixed blades are...
  • Cutting Diameter: 1. 25". Blade Length (ferrule excluded): 77". Model:...
  • Made in the USA.

Common Types Of The Broadheads

Three major types of broadheads are present, and it will pay to grasp the design, pros, and cons of each.

There are 3 main categories of broadheads for you to consider. Each design has its advantages and weaknesses. Here is a quick overview to help you choose the right type for your hunting needs.

1. The Fixed Blade Broadhead

If you like to keep things simple, you will want to stick with a fixed blade broadhead. Most fixed head broadheads screw onto the bolt and are ready for action. Some do require the use of an adhesive to secure the broadhead. These are usually used with lower pull bows and crossbows with speed ratings to a little over 300fps.

Most fixed blade broadheads include a piercing tip which opens the hide making it easier for the blades to slice. The tip is also instrumental in shattering bones as the bolt passes through your game. This is especially important when hunting for larger game like deer, elk, or bear. The fixed blade design means your blade edges take a little extra damage. You will need to sharpen blades when they get dull or nicked.

2. The Replaceable Blade Broadhead

Replaceable blade broadheads are very similar to fixed blade broadheads. They are easy to use, screw on to the bolt easily, and require very little tuning. Their biggest advantage is you can replace the blades quickly when they are dull, instead of sharpening. Your cost will be slightly higher, but it quicker and easier to replace blades than sharpen them. They use penetrating points just like the fixed blade version. These broadheads are not as durable as a fixed blade, so your overall costs will be higher.

3. The Mechanical Broadhead

Expandable, or mechanical, broadheads are considered the most technologically advanced and highest killing power broadheads available. The heads quickly pop open from a small 1” diameter to impressive cutting widths of 2” or greater. They offer better flight patterns due to their small collapsed size until contact. They produce massive wounds which will stop the largest prey within a few steps. The downside is complexity and cost. These broadheads take more fine-tuning and preparation than the other two categories. They are not as durable as either fixed or replaceable blade broadheads. If you want longer shooting capability with higher killing power, and don’t care about durability, this is your broadhead.

Buyer’s Guide: How You Can Choose The Best Hunting Broadheads

Your broadhead can make the difference between a successful shot, or a missed opportunity. Having a high-quality broadhead is essential for accuracy and stopping power. Let’s take a look at a few tips and tricks that will help you choose the right broadheads for your bow hunt.

Legal Note

Mechanical broadheads are not legal in some states. Always check your local hunting laws before ordering your broadheads. Oregon and Idaho forbid the use of mechanical broadheads, while South Dakota and Alaska do not allow them for use on elk. Every state has its own rules and regulations, so check first.

Penetration Capability

Penetration through skin and bone is essential for a successful hunt. You need a broadhead which pierces the skin with ease but is strong enough to pound through the rib bones without deflection. Your broadhead must cut cleanly and continue online to provide game-stopping power. Nothing is more distressing than making the perfect shot and seeing the arrow, or bolt, get deflected.

Perfect Setup

The broadhead is not the only factor in your hunting setup. You need to have the complete setup. You need an arrow with a small diameter and proper balance to deliver those deep penetrating shots.

As one example, a high-quality 500-grain light diameter arrow works perfectly with most fixed blade broadheads. It provides great balance and flight patterns which result in accurate shots. Make sure you look at the entire setup when choosing your broadhead, so you get a combination that works flawlessly.

Flight Trajectory

The larger your blades, the more your flight trajectory is affected by the wind. Small surfaces slice through the air easily, staying on target. This is not a major concern if most of your shots are under 40 yards, but if you plan to stretch your range, choose the most aerodynamic broadhead possible.

Mechanical broadheads offer the least resistance to wind since they are extremely thin before deploying their blades.

Spin is another factor that affects your trajectory. Improper spin can cause your bolt to go off target. You can fine-tune your broadhead to adjust spin. A spin tester can help you get the right balance that provides true flights.

Durable and Sturdy

A sturdy durable design should be at the top of your list. You don’t want to replace broadheads after every shot. Broadheads using carbon steel and stainless steel provide great durability and strength. They resist bending even when blasting through bone and sinew.

Check what materials are used in the construction of the broadhead. Pay attention to how the blades are mounted and what other hunters report about durability. Hardened carbon steel will make it strong, but the design has to be right, or even it will fail. A good broadhead provides durability, piercing power, and accuracy.

Blade Sharpness

A sharp blade is essential to bring down a deer or other large game. It must be able to penetrate easily. A good broadhead can break through bones, cleanly slice through organs and skin, and make an impressive exit wound. The large wound size leads to quicker kills and easy to follow blood trails.

Weight (Grains)

Broadheads vary in weight from around 75 grains up to 150 grains. The two most common weights are 100 and 125-grain. The weight you choose for your broadhead is based on the weight of your arrow. They need to complement each other to provide balance and accurate flight.

The advantage to lighter setups is speed and distance. Heavier setups have the advantage of more stopping power. The heavier weight provides more punch through power making a deeper wound. The 100-grain and 125-grain weights are the most popular because they strike a balance between speed and power.

Your choice of weights depends on the game you are hunting, too. Lighter weights are effective on turkey and deer, but may not provide enough power for elk or bear. The larger the game, the heavier the broadhead and arrow should be.

Your type of equipment will affect your decision, too. A compound bow can easily fire a heavier setup, while a recurve bow requires a lighter setup for accuracy and distance.

Keep in mind, since 100-grain and 125-grain broadheads are the most popular, it is sometimes difficult to find lighter and heavier weights. Check with major producers like Muzzy if you need more options.


Every bow and crossbow hunter will tell you that practice is the key element in accuracy. In their next breath, they will tell you what arrows and broadheads give them the most accuracy. A good broadhead and arrow setup provides greater accuracy with its aerodynamic design and spin.

Shot Placement

Shot placement is a combination of knowledge, accuracy, and broadhead choice. A broadhead that does not deflect provides good flight dynamics, and killing power is key. A properly placed shot results in damage to lungs, heart, and other vital organs dropping your game quickly and humanely.

Check reviews to see what broadheads provide the most accuracy and killing power to improve your shot placement statistics.

Number of Blades

Broadhead usually features 3 or 4 blades. The 3-dimensional design creates wounds that gape open instead of quickly closing. This provides more killing power and is responsible for better blood trails for tracking.

Four-blade broadheads generally provide more impressive wounds but are more expensive and harder to maintain. Three-blade broadheads are easy to maintain and provide good killing power.

Tip types

Fixed-blade broadheads come in chisel points and cut on contact.

Fixed-blade broadheads come with two different types of tips. A chisel point provides a penetrating point before the blades contact the skin. Cut-on-contact tips have the blades as the first point of contact on your prey.

Cut-on-contact blades provide instant cutting through the hide and have deeper penetration. Their disadvantage is deflection. They are easier to knock off the path when they encounter a bone. They are often the first choice of hunters using recurve bows and longbows.

Chisel point tips are the most common style. They have a pointed tip which makes contact before the blades. The chisel can crush through bones keeping the arrow on path providing great stopping power. Chisel points work great with compound bows and crossbows.

Cutting Diameter

The cutting diameter represents the size of the wound the broadhead will make. It is based on the width of the blades on the broadhead.

A large cutting diameter creates a bigger wound which leads to more blood loss, better blood trails, and good stopping power. The disadvantage is penetration. The wider the blade surface, the faster it will slow going through the body. It also increases the chances of the arrow being deflected by bones.

It often seems backward, but it is usually advisable to go with a smaller cutting diameter the larger your game. A smaller diameter will penetrate deeper and avoid deflection providing a better killing force on larger game.

For smaller game, a larger diameter provides quicker stopping power and better blood trails.

Are the blades replaceable?

This one is a personal choice. One-piece designs provide greater simplicity. They are easy to mount, require no adjustments, and work every time.

Replaceable blade broadheads let you keep your blades razor sharp season-after-season. When a blade gets dull or damaged, you replace just the blade, not the entire broadhead. The disadvantage is complexity. You spend extra time removing blades, making sure they are properly secured and balanced.

Each style has its advantages. You just need to choose which one works best for your style of hunting.


How many heads will you use in a hunting season? Every hunter knows that is impossible to answer, but you do know it will be more than one. Missed shots hit rocks and snap the blade. Broadheads pass through the deer and are forever lost. The blades hit a bone and snap.

You know you are going to need extra broadheads and blades on hand, so pricing is a concern. You can save money by buying multi-packs. Most manufacturers offer 3-packs, with a few offering 6-packs, too. You can find high-quality broadheads which will fit any budget.

Which Are the Best Broadheads for Hunters to Use? Fixed Versus Mechanical Broadheads

Advantages and Disadvantages of Fixed Blade

You can get fixed blade broadheads in a number of options, with options of two, three or four blades, and again with a wide range of cutting diameters, grain and shapes. Let us look at the advantages and disadvantages of fixed blade broadheads.

When you need strong penetration for quick and accurate kills, you can get this from fixed blade broadheads that can also offer reliability, durability, easy maintenance, and the ability to tune arrows. You will require a special set of arrows for every bow that you use, as it takes more work to make fixed broadheads fly true.


  • Durability – Once you shoot a fixed blade broadhead there is little that can go wrong with it. Any issue that you have will be there before you are ready to shoot and is a thing you can correct through maintenance, balance, and testing the arrows.
  • Strong Penetration – When you are hunting big game, you will require deep penetration if you are to reach arteries and other vital organs. This is possible if you combine the performance of the broadhead with bow strength, distance and shot placement. Fixed blade broadheads are cut-on-contact types that will give you exceptional penetration. Wind can affect larger broadheads, so the cutting diameter that you use will depend on the power of your bow and the size of the animal being hunted.
  • Ease of Maintenance – When you choose fixed blade broadheads, you can choose a blade that is replaceable, as this allows you to keep the arrows in the best shape, accurately tuned, and have the capacity to cause lethal damage at various distances. Some of these fixed blades are amenable to sharpening and this will extend their life and lead to a saving of money.


  • Flight – Broadheads that are wide will have a greater surface area, and this can cause issues in flight due to the wind when these are shot from the modern compound bows. People who are experienced in hunting will have noticed that the width and size of broadheads are smaller nowadays, compared to what they were in the past. Technology is constantly improving the power and speed of bows, and this has resulted in the reduction in the size of fixed blade broadheads.
  • Tuning – As arrow speeds increase there is a corresponding need for arrow tuning. The setup of your arrow must be tuned to match the bow and the fixed blade heads. Remember that the heavier fixed blades require wider and longer fletching. This can help to balance the arrow for longer and higher distances. The tuning off bows for use with broadheads is an art, that needs to be covered in greater detail.
  • Limitations of Design – Cutting diameter width can affect the tuning capability or accuracy of fixed blade broadheads. The blades that have a wider diameter will not be as stable when they are flying. Greater surface area causes greater friction. This leads to the arrows slowing down and losing accuracy when shot to long distances. This requires greater attention to tuning, a frequency of maintenance and a need for every arrow to have a specific bow.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Mechanical Broadheads

Mechanical broadheads have designs that make for rear or front deployment. They have a conical head design that makes them behave like field points rather than as broadheads, but this can have negative connotations also. Let us look at the advantages and disadvantages of mechanical broadheads.


  • Accuracy – Mechanical arrows have a narrow launch geometry and fly just as a field point would. Compared to fixed blade broadheads they will face less of wind and flight plane issues. As a result, they are more accurate over larger distances, especially outside the 60-yard mark.
  • Inflict more Damage – Cutting angles of mechanical broadheads are wider. Penetration leads the blades to deploy and create tissue damage that is devastating. A fixed blade broadhead will penetrate deeper, but a mechanical broadhead will take out arteries and veins as it penetrates. Hit an organ, and you can rely on greater damage. This damage marginalizes shooter error from poor accuracy. This in no way means that you can forego practice, as the mechanical broadhead does not help you to overcome poor shooting.
  • Wider Path for Cutting – Mechanical broadheads are more useful for smaller animals, whereas fixed blade broadheads are more suitable for large animals, like bear, caribou or elk. Mechanical broadheads give you immediate tissue damage, and smaller game like turkeys have small kill zones.


  • Lower Penetration – When deployed mechanical blades will have wide blade angles. Wide blade angles create more resistance when they strike softer targets. For deeper penetration, you need a narrow blade design, or otherwise a bow that is very powerful. Mechanical broadheads will have a grain of under 100 and this leads to lesser inertia on impact. Both fixed blade and mechanical broadheads can have an issue with blade angles.
  • Game Options Get limited – The decrease in penetrating force means that mechanical broadheads are not the best option for a big game like bear or elk, as their vital organs are deeper and the arrow requires to travel further into the targeted prey to ensure a killing shot.
  • Mechanical Errors – You will rarely have mechanical failures with fixed blade broadheads, but the same cannot be said for mechanical broadheads. At times the blades may not deploy resulting in the animal getting wounded. While this possibility is small, there is a higher risk of arrow failure, as there is more involved in the blade deployment when you compare it to a fixed blade broadhead.

Mechanical or Fixed Blade – Which is Better?

A QDMA study has shown that there is very little difference in the performance of both types of broadhead.

In a target field of 1066 deer, fixed blade broadhead arrows had a recovery of 82 per cent, by bagging 874 of the field targeted.

The recovery with mechanical broadhead arrows was 91 per cent, with 209 of the 230 deer being hit.

Bow Types Matter – Compound bows led to a recovery rate of 89 per cent using mechanical broadheads, while when crossbows were used with mechanical broadheads this resulted in a bag rate of 96 per cent.

Compatibility of Broadhead and Bow

An important question that hunters need to answer is that which compares the compatibility of the broadhead with the type of bow used.

When hunters use traditional bows they often use heavy draw weight arrows so that it makes up for the lagging arrow velocity and to increase the force of penetration. These hunters will use broadheads that measure 300 grains and have heads that ensure penetration on contact. You must never use these traditional bows with expandable broadheads.

Many hunters who use compound bows that have draw weight that varies from 30 to 50 pounds are likely to use the wrong broadhead. When you have bows with a lighter draw it is better to use a cut-on-contact broadhead with two or three blades, instead of a mechanical one. If you do not want to follow this advice, at least use an expandable broadhead that has a cutting diameter of not more than one and a half inches.

When hunters use compound bows that have draw weights of over 50 pounds they then have greater flexibility in the variety of broadheads they can use. Flexibility comes with responsibility, and the placement of the shot becomes important for being a successful hunter.

Which Broadhead Should Be Used For Which Game?

There are many ways that hunters vary. Some hunters like to hunt small animals while others prefer to hunt big game. Some just kill pesky or dangerous animals. Some people prefer bow hunting while others prefer firearms. No matter what your hunting preferences are, the following are some guidelines to use when you are choosing your broadhead to match with the game animals you prefer to hunt.

Rare Big Game Animals

This type of big game animal is not the most popular kind for hunters. However, they are on top of the list when it comes to danger, muscle strength, and hide thickness. To take down animals like oxen, bison, grizzly bears, and moose quickly, humanely, and safely, then hunters should use an all steel, single-piece fixed broadhead.

This type of heavy-duty construction, along with a razor-sharp edge and great hunting skill, is able to break through muscle and bone to quickly hit vital organs. Although an inverse relationship does exist between cutting diameter and penetration, in that case, it might be a good idea to make sure the penetration is deeper in order to finish the kill faster. Those large animals are potentially dangerous and just wounding big game might cause significant problems for a hunter in these situations.

Common Big Game Animals

Many serious hunters go after whitetail deer, wild hogs, and black bears. Many of those animals feature tough hides still, plenty of muscle and potential danger, that require broadheads that are durable and strong. Choose a broadhead that is able to break through the hid and make a big enough wound that allows you to follow the blood. For these game animals, some of the very best broadheads feature replaceable blades and all-steel construction.

Lightweight Animals

These are small species of animals and deer, including some antelope varieties and black-tailed deer, have hides that are much thinner and don’t have the amount of muscle that big game animals do. To hunt lightweight animals, hunts might choose multi-blade, mechanical broadheads, which will puncture the thinner hides easily and expand, and that can generate a blood trail successfully.

Birds and Small Game Animals

Included in this game category are wild turkeys, rabbits, and other pest animals such as coyotes and raccoons. Although it can be hard to vital areas, this type of small game creature has very thin skins that need to be punctured. In this situation, some mechanical broadheads might work, but hunters might want to also look into small game broadheads. Those broadheads result in death by a blunt edge wand followed up by curved blades.

How To Sharpen Broadhead Blades

A sharpening stone is used to sharpen broadheads. Usually, a hunter specifically uses a diamond stone for broadheads. However, a tool-sharpening stone that you can get at the hardware store can work just as well. Use a marker or sharpie to mark each side of the blade to ensure all of them are sharpened.

Attach the broadhead onto the arrow shaft and firmly press it against the stone. Continue applying pressure against the arrow and then move the back and forth in the same direction of the broadhead’s tip. Do that around ten times, and then continue to rotate the broadhead until each side of the blade has been sharpened. Then rotate the broadhead and repeat the process.

Safety Guidelines for Broadheads

Quality broadheads are all very sharp, which is one of their major selling points. Broadheads, unlike bullets, sever the blood vessels which leads to the death of the animal via hemorrhaging. This results in a high risk of hunters being injured from razor-sharp broadheads. The following are some guidelines to help ensure broadheads are used safely and correctly.

  • Use a wrench that has been specifically designed to cover the razor-sharp blade while you are tightening the broadhead into the arrow shaft. When you don’t use this wrench, then a serious injury can result from even a small error.
  • Sharpen the broadheads by ensuring that the movements are not towards your hands or body.
  • Cover the broadheads while you are transporting hunting equipment. Every time you move hunting gear from your house to your vehicle or from your vehicle to the hunting site, then you risk injury when the broadheads are visible.
  • When field-dressing an animal, locate all of the broadhead’s components. Loose parts lost inside of the game may cause injury if you do not practice injury.

Broadheads Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Should I select a 4-blade or 3-blade broadhead?

It all depends on what your personal preference is. 4-blade heads have true flight because they are well-balanced. On the other hand, 3-blade heads cover larger distances and spin better.

Q: Which broadhead is best suited for angled shots?

For angled shots, fixed broadheads work well, but to have greater control over your shot, choose a mechanical broadhead. Massive blood trails and bigger wound channels are provided by the mechanical head.

Q: Which one is better: Mechanical Broadhead or Fixed Broadhead?

Different broadheads are required by different sizes of animals. You need to also consider weather conditions before you choose one. Mechanical broadheads may be better in windy conditions while fixed broadheads are best for backcountry applications.


You want to ensure that your hunting is successful, but you also want to ensure that your kills are ethical. or this you need to have well-designed, good quality broadheads. That is why it is critical for you to be familiar with all of the different kinds that are available, and the types that are suited for different kinds of game that are available in the areas you are planning to hunt in.

Earlier you saw the ups and downs of hybrid fixed and mechanical broadheads. Also, you have learned about the importance of different considerations like the number of blades, material quality, and weight.

The final decision is up to you. Always keep in mind the suggestions that we have provided you with if you want to ensure that your shots hit their targets and that you don’t cause the animals that you intend to hunt to suffer.


Best Broadheads ( Top 3 Picks )

Editor’s Choice & Best Seller
RAGE Crossbow X, 2-Blade Archery Arrow Broadhead, 100 or 125 Grain with Shock Collar Technology (3-Pack)
Professional's Choice
G 5 Outdoors Montec 100 Grain 1-1/16" Cut Broadheads (3 Pack)
Best Value
Muzzy 209-MX4, Bowhunting 100 Grain, .025" 4 Blade Broadhead, 1-1/8" Cutting Diameter, 3 Pack
RAGE Crossbow X, 2-Blade Archery Arrow Broadhead, 100 or 125 Grain with Shock Collar Technology (3-Pack)
G 5 Outdoors Montec 100 Grain 1-1/16" Cut Broadheads (3 Pack)
Muzzy 209-MX4, Bowhunting 100 Grain, .025" 4 Blade Broadhead, 1-1/8" Cutting Diameter, 3 Pack
Our Rating
Editor’s Choice & Best Seller
RAGE Crossbow X, 2-Blade Archery Arrow Broadhead, 100 or 125 Grain with Shock Collar Technology (3-Pack)
RAGE Crossbow X, 2-Blade Archery Arrow Broadhead, 100 or 125 Grain with Shock Collar Technology (3-Pack)
Our Rating
Read Full Review
View on Amazon
Professional's Choice
G 5 Outdoors Montec 100 Grain 1-1/16" Cut Broadheads (3 Pack)
G 5 Outdoors Montec 100 Grain 1-1/16" Cut Broadheads (3 Pack)
Our Rating
Read Full Review
View on Amazon
Best Value
Muzzy 209-MX4, Bowhunting 100 Grain, .025" 4 Blade Broadhead, 1-1/8" Cutting Diameter, 3 Pack
Muzzy 209-MX4, Bowhunting 100 Grain, .025" 4 Blade Broadhead, 1-1/8" Cutting Diameter, 3 Pack
Our Rating
Read Full Review
View on Amazon

Last update on 2020-05-14 / Rating by Author / Affiliate links, Images, Descriptions & Price from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.