20 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots (2020): Buyer’s Guide and Unbiased Reviews

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Are you on a quest to find the most comfortable steel toe boots?

Then you’re in the right place. Because I have done the hard work for you and have reviewed dozens of products to bring you the most comfortable steel toe boots.

In addition, I will introduce the following related topics.

  • Product Details (Including advantages and disadvantages) 
  • Buyer’s Guide
  • Benefits of Comfortable Work Boots
  • Safety Toe Types in Work Boots
  • Maintenance and Care Tips for Work Boots

I will also answer some common questions.

  • What Is The Difference In Standards Between ASTM and ANSI?
  • Are There Differences In The Sizing Of The Steel Toe Boots When Compared To Regular Shoes?
  • Can Steel Toe Boots Be Bad For Your Feet?
  • How Strong Are The Steel Toe Boots?
  • Should Steel Boots Fit Loosely Or Tightly?
  • Is Composite Or Steel Better?
  • How Can I Stop My Feet From Sweating In Steel Toe Boots?
  • How Much Space Should Be In The Toe Area Of The Boot?

Without further ado, let’s begin!

Chief Editor


Hours Researching

Products Evaluated

Reviews Considered

Researched Sources

Top 3 Picks ( In a Hurry? Here are the winners )

Editor’s Choice & Best Seller
Timberland PRO Men's Pitboss 6" Steel-Toe Boot, Brown , 11 D - Medium
Professional's Choice
KEEN Utility Men's Atlanta Cool Steel Toe Work Shoe, 7 D US, Shitake Brown/Black, 7D
Best Value
Servus by Honeywell 18821-12 Comfort Technology 14" PVC Soft Toe Men's Work Boots,Black - Steel Toe,12
Timberland PRO Men's Pitboss 6" Steel-Toe Boot, Brown , 11 D - Medium
KEEN Utility Men's Atlanta Cool Steel Toe Work Shoe, 7 D US, Shitake Brown/Black, 7D
Servus by Honeywell 18821-12 Comfort Technology 14" PVC Soft Toe Men's Work Boots,Black - Steel Toe,12
Price not available
Our Rating
Editor’s Choice & Best Seller
Timberland PRO Men's Pitboss 6" Steel-Toe Boot, Brown , 11 D - Medium
Timberland PRO Men's Pitboss 6" Steel-Toe Boot, Brown , 11 D - Medium
Our Rating
Read Full Review
View on Amazon
Professional's Choice
KEEN Utility Men's Atlanta Cool Steel Toe Work Shoe, 7 D US, Shitake Brown/Black, 7D
KEEN Utility Men's Atlanta Cool Steel Toe Work Shoe, 7 D US, Shitake Brown/Black, 7D
Price not available
Our Rating
Read Full Review
View on Amazon
Best Value
Servus by Honeywell 18821-12 Comfort Technology 14" PVC Soft Toe Men's Work Boots,Black - Steel Toe,12
Servus by Honeywell 18821-12 Comfort Technology 14" PVC Soft Toe Men's Work Boots,Black - Steel Toe,12
Our Rating
Read Full Review
View on Amazon

Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots

For people who spend all day long work out in the field, every day is like a long marathon. Some have to stand all day long on their feet while others need to walk longer distances than the average individual does. So it is these working people who will really understand how important it is to have comfortable work boots.

These people who are doing manual labor on farms, yards, construction sites, and many different industries have to fight fatigue starting with the very first step they take for the day. Having the right pair of shoes to wear promise foot comfort following a long day and protect the toes against hazardous conditions and offer good grip on treacherous surfaces.

You should select footwear that has advanced and proper comfort and support features for people with flat feet, wide feet or various medical conditions like plantar fasciitis or Achilles Tendinitis. Having a good pair of shoes will allow you to do your work without discomfort and pain.

1. Timberland PRO Men’s Pitboss 6″ Steel-Toe Boot – Editor’s Choice & Best Seller

Timberland PRO Men's Pitboss 6" Steel-Toe Boot, Brown , 11 D - Medium
  • STAY ON YOUR FEET: Our Pit Boss is everything a steel toe boot should...
  • SAFETY AND COMFORT: PRO 24/7 Comfort Suspension technology is a unique...
  • A SOURCE OF PRIDE: We know you take pride in your work, so our...
  • QUALITY WORKWEAR: Timberland PRO assesses the unmet needs of those who...
  • TIMBERLAND PRO: Compare the quality workmanship of Timberland PRO work...

These boots from Timberland are safe, tough, and comfortable. ANSI safety standards are met by the special steel toe construction and provides a toe box that is roomier compared to most other boots. Its rubber outsole has slip resistance, oil, and abrasion. Timberland boots won’t cause any foot pain ever after you wear them for an extended period of time. They feature traction-grip that is unsurpassed and works on both wet and slippery surfaces. The boots offer electronic hazard protection that protects against open circuits.

When you wear these work boots, you don’t need to worry about getting blisters after wearing them all day long. The design of the boot is different from the traditional high neck and ankle length. The main highlight of its construction is its 2×4 reinforced stitching. This kind of stitching is used around the sole and joining. The boots offer 24/7 comfort suspension due to the patent technology offering a unique comfort system. The system helps to support your arch and provides a cushioning effect on every step you take.

This is a special technology that reduces foot fatigue. These boots have a steel toe that is in accordance with I/75 and C/75 impact and compression safety standard. The work boots provide the worker’s feet with extra protection with its wide flanged and tempered steel toe cap.

  • Electrical hazard protection
  • Protection from open circuit
  • Padded collar for extra protection
  • The footbed is made out of open-cell polyurethane with an antimicrobial cover
  • Contour nylon shank or plate for shock diffusion
  • Sole might cause discomfort and pain to help people who have flat feet
  • Lack of waterproofing

2. Caterpillar Men’s Second Shift Steel Toe Work Boot

Caterpillar Men's Second Shift Steel Toe Work Boot, Dark Brown, 10.5 W US
  • Ankle-cut work boot with steel toe with padded ankle and oil-resistant...

These Caterpillar boots are ideal for both heavy and light use. The boot is comprised of Nubuck leather uppers and they also come with Goodyear welt construction. The fact that they are made out of full-grain leather is a major advantage since it helps to prevent water from penetrating into the inside.

The Goodyear welt construction we discussed previously is one of the major strengths of this work boot since it helps to make the shoe last a long time if when used in tough conditions and environments. Another important feature of these boots is the internal nylon mesh lining.

The moisture-wicking ability means you can expect that your feet will stay dry. Another great thing about the footwear is they come with the Climasphere internal sock, and it works to keep you either warm or cool depending on what the current temperature is.

With slip-resistant outsoles integrated into this shoe, you will also receive some type of guarantee that it is very durable and also has good traction. The boot is highly breathable due to the nylon mesh lining.

With its high electrical hazard protection and lace-up closures, you will stay safe no matter what the conditions are like that you are working in.

The problem with the work boot is it takes about one week for you to break them in, so during this time you can expect to develop some blisters.

  • Works well with both heavy or light use no matter what the conditions and work environment is like
  • Prevents water from being able to penetrate inside – due to its full-grain leather construction
  • Highly breathable with assistance from its nylon mesh lining
  • Slip-resistant outsoles, which makes the shoe safe and durable
  • Secure and safe – due to its lace-up closure with high electrical hazard protection
  • You must spend one week at least to break the boots in

3. Servus Comfort Technology 14″ PVC Soft Toe Men’s Work Boots – Steel Toe – Best Value

Servus by Honeywell 18821-12 Comfort Technology 14" PVC Soft Toe Men's Work Boots,Black - Steel Toe,12
  • PVC polyblend injection molded construction is seamless and 100%...
  • CT (Comfort Technology) offers a unique scalloped top-line for easy...
  • Lightweight FOOT FORM contour cushion insole provides arch and heel...
  • Deep angle cleated outsole prevents slips and falls on slippery...
  • Recommended use: food processing, custodial, farm, general purpose

These boots are ideal for protecting you from harsh chemicals, mud, rain, and various impacts. The special injection mold OVC boots are also waterproof and have been designed to resist deterioration from hard chemicals and fertilizers that are found on work sites. The boot’s steel toe provides maximum impact protect against heavyweight falling objects from the work site. They have been designed to provide you with maximum comfort throughout the workday.

The safety footwear comes with contour molded hells that lock your heel into place and helps to prevent it from slipping around inside of the boot while you are walking. They have the unique Trac10 outsole to provide maximum traction while on greasy surfaces. They are flexible and soft to wear in cold weather and provide easy movement. They have been designed using CT comfort technology for accommodating flexing to provide extra comfort.

This all-day lightweight comfort safety footwear offers contour cushion with outstanding arch and heel support. It is removable and washable. You also get the added advantage of durability and impact protection.

  • Durable and comfortable
  • Very thick sole
  • Ideal for maximum protection against chemicals
  • Stylish looking books
  • The inner lining protects your feet from slipping
  • Might run narrow

4. Timberland PRO Men’s 26038 Direct Attach 6″ Steel Toe Boot

Timberland PRO Men's 26038 Direct Attach 6" Steel Toe Boot,Black,10.5 M
  • CLASSIC TIMBERLAND: These rugged work boots are built to keep you...
  • TIMBERLAND PRO 24/7 COMFORT SYSTEM: A comfort system that helps reduce...
  • A SOURCE OF PRIDE: We know you take pride in your work, so our...
  • QUALITY WORKWEAR: Timberland PRO assesses the unmet needs of those who...
  • TIMBERLAND PRO: Compare the quality workmanship of Timberland PRO work...

If you have ever worn the 6-inch original Timberland, this specific boot looks similar to it but has more features promising safety and comfort on the work site. Some of the very best features with this boot include the 400 grams worth of insulation that provides warmth, oil resistant outsole, and seam-sealed waterproof upper with outstanding traction. The footbed comes with an antimicrobial treatment so you don’t need to worry about foot odor either. It also comes with a nylon shock diffusion plate that provides your feet with great support particular during long work shifts.

Loaded with innovative technology and features, this footwear is the classic style work boot. It has it all and then some. When Timberland designed these boots they were very serious about creating a work boot that would be able to withstand rugged use. They are a bit more expensive compared to other steel toe boots from Timberland but are definitely worth considering all of the comfort and safety features for you to enjoy. There are also various colors that you can choose from including wheat, brown, yellow, and classic black.

  • Waterproof insulated upper and lace-up vamp
  • Comfortable even on long shifts
  • Generous 400 grams of insulation provides warm
  • Durable and solid construction
  • The boot might be too heavy for some people
  • Not the best for users who have wide feet
  • Sizes run small

5. KEEN Utility Men’s Atlanta Cool Steel Toe Work Shoe – Professional’s Choice

KEEN Utility Men's Atlanta Cool Steel Toe Work Shoe, 7 D US, Shitake Brown/Black, 7D
  • Torsional Stability Shank
  • Removable metatomical dual density eva footbed
  • Dual density compression molded Eva footbed
  • Left and Right asymmetrical steel toes

Keen is a leading US brand of extremely comfortable work shoes and boots. They have a large variety to choose from and they are definitely one of the well-established brands.

This steel toe work shoe from Keen is a low-cut shoe that is very stylish and also well-suited for almost any working environment. The upper of this boot is made out of mesh and leather and the combination ensures that you not only will you get the best durability, but optimal ventilation as well.

The measurement of the heel is around 1.25 inches from its arch and when that is considered with the rubber lugs pattern on the outer sole, so you shouldn’t have any problems getting through oil spills and water.

It also comes with a dual-density molded EVA midsole and since we frequently get tired of standing on our feet all day long, we have discovered that the midsole molds to the shape of the feet perfectly. That makes the shoe ideal for supination and pronation and should help to ensure that you don’t get too fatigued when wearing them.

The boots are very reasonably priced and you need to know that quality is a bit more expensive. These boots work better for warmer days compared to wetter and colder working environments, we have they are best-suited for people who work in construction or inside of factories. The steel toe is very heavy but gives you an additional layer of safety.

  • Moldable EVA midsole
  • Oil and water resistant
  • Reasonably priced
  • Offers great ventilation
  • Comfortable and small design
  • Are Not waterproof

6. KEEN Utility Men’s Pittsburgh Steel Toe Work Boot

KEEN Utility mens Pittsburgh 6" Steel Toe Work Boot, Bison Brown/Red, 11D
  • Locking metal lace hooks
  • Removable metatomical dual density eva footbed
  • Dual density compression molded Eva and PU midsole
  • Left and Right asymmetrical steel toes

Pittsburgh is a tough steel city and these utility work boots from Keen are as well. They are ready for whatever you happen to throw at them – quite literally. The boots come with numerous features, including a waterproof breathable membrane, slip resistant outer sole, as well as waterproof and weatherproof lining. They feature an ASTM-rated steel tool. The boot really gets the job done. With waterproof and weatherproof outside and inside lining, this footwear is ready for your feet and the weather. No matter what, these boots will keep your feet completely dry.

You won’t have to worry about slipping and falling in these boots since they feature a slip-resistant outer sole. With these shoes, no matter where you work you’ll be able to keep a grip. The Keen Utility Pittsburgh is more expensive than some of the other boots on our list. However, when you consider all the extra features that are offered, they really should cost more. These are the boots to buy if you want to get the most for your money.

  • Weatherproof and Waterproof
  • Stands up to harsh conditions
  • Lighter than some other boots
  • Hard soles

7. KEEN Utility Men’s Flint Low Steel Toe Work Shoe

KEEN Utility Men's Flint Low Steel Toe Work Shoe, 7.5EE, Shitake Brown/Rust
  • Left and Right Asymmetrical Steel Toes
  • Nubuck Waterproof Leather Upper
  • Torsional Stability Shank (TSS) for Midfoot Support
  • Removable Metatomical Dual Density EVA Footbed
  • Oil- and Slip-Resistant Non-Marking Outsole

One of the major strengths of these steel toe work shoes is they have been designed in a way that transforms them into durable and protective footwear that is capable footwear that can provide the same comfort that an outdoor shoe can.

It features a well-cushioned footbed, and that is one of the main reasons why it feels great even the first time that you wear these shoes – it isn’t necessary to have a long break-in period with this footwear. This steel toe work boot comes with a stability shank as well, which offers resilient support for the wearer.

Another surprising benefit offered by the steel toe boot is that it’s lightweight, which makes wearing it even more convenient. The boot comes with mesh panels for promoting proper air circulation, which is very helpful when you are working in a very hot climate.

The removable footbed and compression molded EVA midsole provide additional comfort. This footwear also takes great pride in the many safety features it offers, including its oil and water-resistant outsole and full electrical hazard protection.

It also comes with a well-designed ladder lock that provides additional protection. This is honestly one of the most durable steel toe boot around since it makes use of the strongest and sturdiest construction techniques and materials.

The only problem that this work shoe has it that it doesn’t offer a puncture-proof shank. Suppodely that really helps to provide wearers with more protection.

  • No long-break-in period is required
  • Well-cushioned footbed makes it very comfortable
  • Mesh panels that offer the right air circulation
  • A stability shank that provides resilient support
  • Numerous safety features, including a well-designed ladder lock, oil and water-resistant outsole, and EH protection
  • No puncture-proof shank

8. New Balance Men’s MID627 Steel-Toe Work Shoe

New Balance Men's mid627, Brown, 8 2E US
  • Steel toe work shoe with athletic cushion and flexibility
  • Static Dissipative construction
  • ABZORB cushioning
  • Slip-resistant

These boots are dedicated to helping ensure that hard-working women and men can achieve their goals. This steel toe work shoe takes style and safety to an entirely new level.

The shoes have been designed with people like you in mind. They provide plenty of cushioning and comfort all day long. As you are working, the shoes work overtime, to shield and protect your feet against hazards and dangers in the workplace.

The heel has a steep design that helps to relax your feet, along with the electrical insulation. The footwear’s tough outsole is oil and water-resistant to provide long-lasting protection against greasy surfaces.

This steel toe shoe is second-to-none. It provides your toes with a shield as you are going about your business and getting the job done. Due to the athletic design of the shoes, they will keep you feeling energetic and sporty all day.

  • Arched heel drop
  • Cushioning provided by injection-molded EVA foam midsole
  • Slip- and oil-resistant
  • The material covering on the steel wears off easily and doesn’t last long
  • It is heavy compared to other brands
  • Doesn’t fit all large foot sizes
  • The steel toes are not right and left asymmetrical
  • Limited waterproof property

9. Dr. Martens Men’s Icon Industrial Strength Steel Toe Boot

Dr. Martens - Men's Icon 2295 Steel Toe Heavy Industry Boots, Black, 11 M US
  • Import from: China
  • Commercial Brand: DR. MARTENS
  • Gloves

These work boots are from another well-known and renowned shoe brand. They are made out of water-resistant leather, so they will definitely keep your feet nice and dry. They are heat resistant along with being water resistant. The boot is also traditional PVC work boot apparel and features a cleated sole along with a wooden shank to provide mid-foot rigidity. The footwear is slip resistant as well.

Protection is centered on the ankles by this footwear to ensure added impact resistance. That means that along with protecting your toes, your ankles are as well. That is a very important feature for anyone to have who works in a profession such as farming where the ankles might be at risk.

These Dr. Martens boots, unlike many of the others that are on our list, are electrical hazard-resistant. That is very important for anybody who might work around electricity. It is one of the mid-priced boots on our least, although it can found at a less expensive price as well, which given all of the features that it offers is surprising.

  • Easy Break In Period
  • Excellent Traction
  • Slip-Ons, Don’t Have To Bother With Laces
  • Might Have To Order One Size Bigger

10. Skechers for Work Men’s Workshire Relaxed Fit Work Steel Toe Boot

You would be mistaken if you thought that only causal and sports footwear are made by Sketchers. When we were searching for budget-friendly steel toe boots out on the market these steel toe boots from Skechers.

Although not completely on par with Caterpillar and Timberland work shoes when it comes to durability and quality, this work boot from Sketchers surprisingly does offer many good things. The shoes are fairly lightweight for one thing. Although most steel toe boots are heavy, these are lighter due to the lightweight and innovative alloy safety toes feature. Also, the outsoles are slip-resistant. Overall, these shoes have met and also exceeded many safety standards.

For a nice custom fit these steel toe boots from Sketchers also come with a Relaxed Fit trademark. As long as you make sure to get the right size for your feet, then you will absolutely love how comfortable and great these work boots feel. What’s even better is these boots are relatively less expensive compared to many other brands as well. It is quite rare to find a high-quality work boot at an affordable price so you should definitely grab these while they are still available at such as a reasonable price.

  • Tough yet lightweight design
  • Slip-resistant outsole
  • Relatively less expensive
  • Relaxed Fit design for comfortable and custom fit
  • Sizes run large
  • Too narrow
  • Doesn’t provide the best insulation

More Products (Our Rating: 4 Stars)

11. Skechers for Work Men's Soft Stride Steel Toe Work Shoe
12. KEEN Utility Men's Detroit Mid Steel Toe Work Boot
KEEN Utility Men's Detroit Mid Steel Toe Work Boot,Slate Black,10.5 D US
  • Left and Right Asymmetrical Steel Toes
  • KEEN.DRY waterproof breathable membrane
  • Nubuck Waterproof Leather Upper
  • Torsional Stability Shank (TSS) for Midfoot Support
  • Dry-lex footwear lining with hydrophobic/hydrophilic two-zone comfort...
13. Caterpillar Men's Brode Steel-Toe Work Shoe
Caterpillar Men's Brode Steel-Toe Work Shoe
  • Low-top leather work shoe with lace-up closure and steel toe
  • Logoing at sides and tongue
  • Steel Toe Rating: ASTM F2413-11 M/I/75 C/75 EH
14. Timberland PRO Men's Titan Safety Toe Oxford
Timberland PRO Men's Titan Safety Toe Oxford,Haystack Brown,7 M
  • Leather oxford with safety toe featuring lace front with metal...
  • PowerFit comfort system
15. Caterpillar Men's Revolver Pull-On Steel-Toe Boot
Caterpillar mens Revolver Pull-on Steel Toe Work Boot, Dark Brown, 9.5 W US
  • Slightly distressed steel-toe boot in full-grain leather construction
  • Dual pull handles with contrast logo patch
  • Slip-resistant outsole
  • Nylon Mesh Lining ; P89516 Taibrelle + Pu Sock Liner ; PVC Midsole ;T3...
16. Thorogood Men's American Heritage 8
Thorogood 804-4208 Men's American Heritage 8" Moc Toe, MAXwear Wedge Safety Toe, Tobacco Oil-Tanned - 7 D US
  • Thorogood's Exclusive Oil & Slip Resistant Polyurethane MAXwear...
  • Rubber Midsole. Traditional lace-up work boot with metal eyelets and...
  • Electrical Hazard Rated
17. Wolverine Men's Floorhand 6 Inch Waterproof Steel Toe Work Shoe
Wolverine Men's Floorhand Waterproof 6" Steel Toe Work Boot, Black, 7 M US
  • Waterproof full-grain leather upper to keep your feet dry in wet...
  • A strong steel toe that meets astm standard f2413-11 m I/75 c75 eh
  • Slip resistant rubber lug outsole to safely keep your footing in...
  • Lightweight cement construction
18. Thorogood Men's American Heritage 6
Thorogood 804-4200 Men's American Heritage 6" Moc Toe, MAXwear Wedge Safety Boot, Tobacco Oil-Tanned - 10.5...
  • Tobacco Oil-Tanned 804-4200 or Black 804-6201, full-grain leather
  • Removable Ultimate Shock Absorption Footbed on Poron comfort cushion...
  • Fiberglass shank
  • MAXWear Wedge slip resistant outsole
  • Goodyear storm welt construction
19. Muck Boots Chore Classic Tall Steel Toe Men's Rubber Work Boot
Muck Chore Classic Tall Steel Toe Men's Rubber Work Boots
  • 5 mm neoprene provides comfort and flexibility, along with excellent...
  • 100% waterproof work boots, easy-to-clean high-grade rubber overlay...
  • Breathable Air mesh lining wicks away humidity and perspiration, and...
  • Steel shank for support; triple toe and quadruple rubber heel...
20. Wolverine Men's W08289 Wolverine steel toed Boot
Wolverine Men's W08289 Wolverine Steel Toe Boot,Honey,8.5 XW US
  • These Moc-Toe boost are perfect for all-day comfort while going from...
  • Steel toe rated ASTM F2413-11 M I/75 C/75 EH
  • Full-grain leather upper
  • Nylon shank helps add stability and relieves stress and fatigue
  • Removable footbed

Benefits of Comfortable Work Boots

Comfort is crucial when your job involves standing or walking throughout a working day. Making sure that your feet have the right support and posture can help your job to become more enjoyable and easier.

The Right Amount of Foot Support

The correct stance for each foot is necessary when it comes to assisting with your body balance. Any issues can easily throw your body off-balance entirely which can result in pain and discomfort in your joints. The best type of work boot will promote better body and foot health.

Lowers Stress

As you walk, your feet carry your body’s entire weight. Footwear that is unsupportive can result in fatigue and unnecessary stress on your feet. The correct pair of lightweight footwear can also be used with specific health problems in the way of accommodating orthotics.

Reduces the Risks of Injuries

Shoes of high-quality will equally disperse impact and shock forces while lowering the impact to your lower back, hips, knees, and your feet. These shoes can drastically reduce the risks associated with injuries to your lower body.

Increases Productivity

Work boots that are comfortable will keep your feet much happier and your body healthier, even after the longest days at work. The cushioning in these shoes relieves pressure and will help you to feel more energetic as you go about your day.

Safety Toe Types in Work Boots

The safety toe features are one of the best inventions for individuals that work outdoors. This particular feature has saved many people from a number of different injuries over the last few decades. In fact, using comfortable and high-quality safety shoes has become a requirement in a number of different professions.

These shoes come in a few different styles, yet every version performs the same function which includes toe protection.

Steel Toes

This is the heaviest and most classic out of all these options. The benefit to these safety toes is that they seal the area of the toes completely, which offers the ultimate protection for working conditions that are regarded as treacherous. In fact, a few companies insist that every worker has to wear steel-toe boots when they are at work.

These shoes are durable enough to protect your toes from sharp and large falling objects, from accidentally bumping into a hard surface, and protection from electrical hazards. Most models feature electrical-hazard ratings which can protect you from electrocution or shocks.

Aluminum Toes

These toe protectors are thinner and lighter than steel, yet still, provide the same level of durability and strength. These safety toes consist of an alloy which combines titanium and aluminum, which provides superior protection from impacts and injury. The thinner silhouette provides more space in the area of the toes which are an added benefit for the workers that have wide feet.

One of the drawbacks about aluminum toes is that this material is sensitive when it comes to temperature, which means they may not be the best option for extremely hot or cold environments.

Composite Toes

These toes are made from either plastic, Kevlar, or carbon fiber, and is to date the lightest available option. These toes provide ample protection against impacts and bumps. This type of material is also suitable for all types of temperatures.

Alloy Toes

The alloy protection toe-caps provide the very same protection properties as steel, yet they weigh much less. This toe type is usually thicker when compared to the steel toes, yet they are a fantastic choice for those in search of footwear that is lighter in weight. For this reason, the alloy toe-caps are more commonly used for more sports-orientated and lighter safety shoes, whereby the wearer requires mobility and protection at the same time. These protective caps are also able to bend when placed under pressure instead of snapping or breaking.

Soft Toes

Even though protective toe caps are essential and important for the safety of workers, there are situations which make them unnecessary where they may even detract from the user’s functionality and overall comfort of the shoe. If you work in an environment where there are no dangers present when it comes to crushing, stubbing or bumping your toes, it may be better to look at other features that are more imminent. The soft-toe boots or non-protective toe boot come with their own protective properties without the need to include components that encumber your toes. For instance, if your job involves shoveling materials such as sawdust or clearing areas of oil or water spills, a slip-resistant shoe would be more important than the shoe that features protective toe-caps.

Buyer’s Guide: The Main Features to Look for When Shopping for the Best Steel Toe Boots

Choosing steel-toe boots which are comfortable is not always an easy option as there is some level of criteria needed to discern between average and the Best Steel Toe Boots. Here is a buyer’s guide to assist you with simplifying the process of choosing and to make sure you are getting the very best value when it comes to the money that you will be spending. Here are some of the more important features to look for in this type of boot:

1. Durability

The best shoes should be able to last for many years, along with the stress and abuse they are put through associated with hazards on job sites. Not many people have $100 or more to spend on a pair of work boots only to find they need to be replaced after a few months.

Brand names are also not always the best indication that the boot is sturdy and long-lasting. It is important to look at the upper materials, the insole quality, tread thickness, toe construction, along with the build overall which will contribute to the strength of these boots. The type of structure will also play an important role.

Synthetic or leather welt is the more common methods which involve a material strip which is stitched with the lower and upper sole. This results in a durable and rugged construction that will usually last for many years. It also provides a way to replace the bottoms when they start to wear down.

This direct technique uses a type of elastic material which is used for attaching the soles. This includes molten rubber which is poured between the outsole and the upper. Once these materials harden the end result is a very lightweight structure which is excellent for absorbing impact.

Another technique is known as the cementing method, which uses a pliant, high-strength adhesive which attaches the upper parts to the outsoles. This is the most cost-effective option which results in very light shoes. However, with this method, you would be left with no option than to throw away your shoes when the sole detaches or breaks off.

2. Materials

Leather is one of the oldest and most traditional materials used for working boots. However, today there are various brands that manufacture their products with high-quality mesh and synthetic materials which are made to be highly durable and they also feature a high-level when it comes to abrasion and tear resistance.

These outsoles are usually made from synthetic rubber as this reduces the overall weight of the boots and also provides the structure with a sufficient amount of pliability which acts as a durable shield when it comes to high impacts.

The shank shapes and materials are also very important when it comes to adding stability along with assisting with the correct posture. These shanks come in fiberglass, plastic, and steel which will depend on what type of condition your feet are in.

3. Adjustable and Sizing Options

This is to ensure that the fit is correct. Your boots should not have too much room, be too narrow, short or tight. To prevent grazed skin, footsore, blisters, and any other associated issues, you first need to establish whether the boots follow the sizes linked to the well-known brands. Also, find out whether they have laces or straps to improve the adjustment.

4. Weight

When you are using your Best Steel Toe Boots when you are at work on construction sites or for outdoor areas, you most likely spend many hours standing or walking. To assist with delaying fatigue, your shoes need to be lightweight as well as easy and comfortable to move in. The overall weight of the boot is vital, and because these boots come with a steel toe that is heavy, look for the light shanks such as the composite toe or alloy toe.

5. Comfort

The cushioning in boots are typically located in 4 regions which include: the insole, upper, outsole and midsole. While the insoles are usually the most common area for comfort and cushioning, the midsoles are not as well-known, while the outsoles are not usually linked with cushioning.

Insoles are the area where you will expect the majority of the cushioning to be. This usually comes in the form of heel pads, foam footbeds, a cushioned forefoot, along with others. In general, many shoes will use insole pieces and foam insoles, yet some manufacturers also use gel-based components and compounds.

The midsole gel and foam cushions are what really adds comfort to a shoe that is well-cushioned. This is a part of a shoe which features cushioning components that are the most effective. In order to increase the overall lifespan of a gel or foam midsole, the designs include wedging these midsoles between the outsole and insole. Insoles are in direct contact with your feet and will wear down faster. In addition, the outsole will be on the exterior of the shoe which also wears down faster due to contact with the ground. This is the reason why most manufacturers will use the best technologies for cushioning in the midsole.

As mentioned previously, outsoles are generally not linked to cushioning. The outsoles rather serve as a barrier for your foot and the ground. It serves the purpose of protecting the feet from abrasive surfaces, rocks, chemicals, and other common workplace threats. The outsole of a shoe is also made to protect the feet from impact and shock. Synthetic and rubber materials are more commonly used materials. These materials are designed to disperse and absorb shock.

Another form of cushioning includes padded uppers which can protect your feet from scrapes and bumps by providing a type of protective barrier for the top part of your feet. This padding comes in padded collars, padded tongues, and padded linings. The shoes that do not feature this type of protection between each foot and the hard or firm exterior of the leather shoe, may be too abrasive and might cut into the Achilles tendon of your foot.

6. The Soles

This is another important element that will determine the overall comfort level of the boot. The excessive cushioning in the insoles are the best choice for the workers that remain immobile for many hours or when they work in environments with constant vibrations.

Yet, a highly cushioned sole is not the right choice for workers that are constantly moving around. This is when EVA midsoles are the ideal choice for impact and stress resistance. The outsoles on these shoes should have a good degree of flex to ensure improved foot contact when walking and redistributing energy to key areas which help to lower fatigue.

7. The Break-In Period

This will depend on the leather quality and the type of fabrics used for the lining and the upper. The full-grain leather that comes with a padded collar along with cushioned layers will take a lot less time to break-in. However, in most cases, working boots are usually rugged and tough. It is standard for these types of shoes to take a month sometimes more to feel completely comfortable.

8. Waterproof

While none of these boots are waterproof as this is regarded as one of the work-specific requirements, we still suggest making sure the outer sole is at least waterproof. Even though these shoes are usually slip-resistant, if your outsoles are not waterproof, your feet may get wet when you head outdoors in rainy or wet conditions. If you work outside, then a waterproof boot or waterproof features should be your main concern.

9. Protection

There are many industries and sectors that require that their workers wear a steel-toed boot. Some of the misconceptions that surround this type of shoe is that if something had to fall on the shoe they would break or cut off your toes. This is definitely not true which has been shown time and time again. Some people are also under the illusion that standard work boots are enough to keep you safe. Yet when compared side by side, the regular working boots fail to offer the benefits and features associated with steel toe boots.

While the steel-toe boots are classified as a type of protective footwear which features steel caps in the area of the toe, this feature will protect the toes on each foot from various types of situations. Here are a few things that steel caps can protect your toes from:

  • Crushing caused by a heavy falling item
  • From blades like chainsaws
  • Protection from objects that may roll over your toes
  • Fractures
  • Punctures
  • Anti-static
  • Hot metal that might burn through another type of shoe
  • Electrical protection
  • Compression resistance
  • Heat resistance

Some of the steel-toe boots also come with steel plates in the bottom part of these boots which protects your feet from punctures. Depending on what type of job you do, employers may have a highly specific type that you will need to purchase. In our guide, we provide different options when it comes to the Best Steel Toe Boots which will keep your feet feeling comfortable and protected.

10. Slip Resistant

All the heavy-duty jobs must involve a shoe that is slip resistant. There are usually two primary ways that manufacturers achieve this feature. This includes either widening the design of these lugs or adding in hardened outer soles. This makes these outer soles resistant to slipping and are usually the ideal choice for water or oil spills in a workplace.

11. Inner Sole

Inner soles have a direct effect on how comfortable the shoe will be, which means the best inner sole designs will mean you can wear your shoes for many hours in comfort. PU cushioning and memory foam are better options. If you are looking for boots for either supination or pronation, the EVA foam insoles are the best choice.

12. The Shank

The shank becomes important when you are deciding between a high-cut or mid-cut design boot. These shanks are usually made from fiberglass or metal which will contribute to the weight of the boot along with the support that you need. Metal shanks are far more durable, which is the better option for heavier people, while fiberglass is more suitable when you want a more efficient and lighter shoe. Fiberglass shanks will usually contribute to a more expensive boot.

13. The Lining

The lining on the inside of a work boot is important for protecting against abrasions and to keep your feet warm. Gore-Tex is usually recommended if you plan to use your boots outdoors, yet for indoor use, you can also consider the standard textile fabrics. These linings will also help to keep water and moisture out of your boots, which adds another layer of protection.

14. Electricity Resistant

This is not a feature that applies to all workers, yet if you work in the construction industry, this feature will add safety to your boots when it comes to electrical issues. This is a feature usually included in the outer soles and also increases the overall price of these boots.

15. Ventilation

This is not regarded as a safety feature, yet this will make a significant difference to your shoes. In summer, your boots might get hot inside, and the right amount of ventilation will increase your comfort levels. The ventilation is usually provided through mesh uppers, yet you should first make sure that these boots are also waterproof.

16. Antimicrobial Properties

Antimicrobial properties of a working boot will help to ensure your boots stay clean, and to inhibit the growth of bacteria inside your boots. These properties will also help to protect your feet from odors and infections.

Maintenance and Care Tips for Work Boots

Taking care of your steel-toe boots should not be expensive or difficult. However, it is still important to follow maintenance and care procedures to ensure your boots last for as long as possible. Below are a few handy tips you can use to take care of your boots.

  • Try and keep your shoes as dry and clean as possible. This tip is essential to the longevity of steel-toe boots. If you fail to regularly clean the boots, mud, dust, and dirt may cause them to quickly deteriorate. Make sure you brush the boots as often as you can to remove any contaminants.
  • Wash your boots well at least once a month to make sure they stay as clean as possible. Begin with taking out the insoles and shoelaces before your remove dirt and dust from the shoes. Use a solution of boot cleaner and water to clean the shoes. Make sure that you scrub gently ensuring you remove all traces of dirt without causing any damages to the outside leather. Use a gentle dish cleaner if you do not have the appropriate boot cleaner. Avoid detergents or bar soaps, and this can dry out the boots causing the leather to crack.
  • Rinse the boots with clean water and allow to dry in a room that is well-ventilated. Avoid drying your shoes in sunlight. You can, however, use a fan in the room to speed up the drying process.
  • The last step involves applying a waterproof wax or cream. It is a good idea to apply this waterproof layer every few weeks if your shoes come into contact with water frequently. The best way to determine whether you boots need waxing will be to splash a bit of water over the boots. If the water doesn’t bead up it is time to apply another layer.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is The Difference In Standards Between ASTM and ANSI?

ANSI stands for American National Standards Insitute and ASTM stands for American Standard Test Method.

There are various sections associated with standards which have to be adhered to in different industry fields. The Test Method involves how manufacturers of these boots are required to test their products to make sure that match up the specifications that are set by the ANSI. This actually means that there is no difference when it comes to the specifications between ASTM and ANSI. They go hand-in-hand to ensure the manufacturing companies are meeting up to these requirements.

Are There Differences In The Sizing Of The Steel Toe Boots When Compared To Regular Shoes?

Every shoe manufacturer may involve sizes which will be different when compared to another brand. If you expect to wear one size for every type of shoe, this is slightly unrealistic. Certain brands will fit narrow, and others will ask you for exact measurements. Some may even suggest ordering a size down or up.

Can Steel Toe Boots Be Bad For Your Feet

The steel-toe work boots are classified as a type of safety shoe. They are designed to protect the feet in hazardous working environments. Some people believe that these shoes can be bad for the feet when wearing them for extended periods. This might be true in certain instances. For example, when you buy work boots that do not fit properly or they do not meet the important criteria of providing safety, durability, and comfort.

How Strong Are The Steel Toe Boots?

With the steel components, these shoes are designed to protect feet from heavy falling objects and injuries, more specifically these shoes are able to:

  • Protect the feet when something as heavy as 75 lbs falls from 3 feet onto your feet. If you were wearing regular shoes, your toes would break or be severely crushed.
  • Protect the feet from sharp and heavy objects, which could cause damages to your feet if you had to stumble over them.

Should Steel Boots Fit Loosely Or Tightly?

They should fit comfortably. They should also be breathable, and they should never feel tight to ensure that your feet remain safe.

Is Composite Or Steel Better?

Each of these types come with their own benefits. Some people prefer the composite toe caps as the shoes are lighter, while others prefer steel-toe boots as they guarantee the ultimate protection.

How Can I Stop My Feet From Sweating In Steel Toe Boots?

  • Choose a lightweight and breathable boot
  • Use absorbent socks
  • Use foot powder
  • Give your feet a bit of time in order to breathe

How Much Space Should Be In The Toe Area Of The Boot?

1 inch of space is ideal.

Final Thoughts

The most comfortable and best steel-toe boots is a very important investment for your profession. Without the right shoes, you may feel pain and discomfort while you work. For this reason, make sure you choose the boots that will keep you secure, comfortable and safe while on the job.


Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots ( Top 3 Picks )

Editor’s Choice & Best Seller
Timberland PRO Men's Pitboss 6" Steel-Toe Boot, Brown , 11 D - Medium
Professional's Choice
KEEN Utility Men's Atlanta Cool Steel Toe Work Shoe, 7 D US, Shitake Brown/Black, 7D
Best Value
Servus by Honeywell 18821-12 Comfort Technology 14" PVC Soft Toe Men's Work Boots,Black - Steel Toe,12
Timberland PRO Men's Pitboss 6" Steel-Toe Boot, Brown , 11 D - Medium
KEEN Utility Men's Atlanta Cool Steel Toe Work Shoe, 7 D US, Shitake Brown/Black, 7D
Servus by Honeywell 18821-12 Comfort Technology 14" PVC Soft Toe Men's Work Boots,Black - Steel Toe,12
Price not available
Our Rating
Editor’s Choice & Best Seller
Timberland PRO Men's Pitboss 6" Steel-Toe Boot, Brown , 11 D - Medium
Timberland PRO Men's Pitboss 6" Steel-Toe Boot, Brown , 11 D - Medium
Our Rating
Read Full Review
View on Amazon
Professional's Choice
KEEN Utility Men's Atlanta Cool Steel Toe Work Shoe, 7 D US, Shitake Brown/Black, 7D
KEEN Utility Men's Atlanta Cool Steel Toe Work Shoe, 7 D US, Shitake Brown/Black, 7D
Price not available
Our Rating
Read Full Review
View on Amazon
Best Value
Servus by Honeywell 18821-12 Comfort Technology 14" PVC Soft Toe Men's Work Boots,Black - Steel Toe,12
Servus by Honeywell 18821-12 Comfort Technology 14" PVC Soft Toe Men's Work Boots,Black - Steel Toe,12
Our Rating
Read Full Review
View on Amazon

Last update on 2020-04-03 / Rating by Author / Affiliate links, Images, Descriptions & Price from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.